Looking at 5 Mishaps From GM Jim Nill

Since taking over as general manager in the summer of 2013, Jim Nill has been among the NHL’s best at his job, turning a once-playoff no-show Dallas Stars into a postseason regular.
1) Matt Dumba
Looking to get bigger and more scrappy, Nill targeted a physical player. That 2024 Western Conference Finals loss to the Edmonton Oilers showed the team that being strictly skill-based isn’t gonna cut it in the playoffs. So Nill acquired Matt Dumba before the 2025 season. Nill paid Dumba like the Stars were desperate for physicality too, as Dallas was at the bottom of the league in the hits stats.
The Stars got a little extra grit that off-season. The problem was that Dumba couldn’t stay in the lineup nightly as his production hurt the team. Dumba was good at sticking up for his team when the opposition got aggressive. But too many goals against nullified the enforcer role Nill brought him in for, and Dumba didn’t see any ice time in the postseason.
Dumba didn’t fare well in Dallas. So he got traded to the Pittsburgh Penguins after 2025 concluded.
2) Illya Lybushkin
Another example of Nill overpaying for a big defenseman who couldn’t help the Stars in any regard. At best, he was a serviceable defensive defenseman. But a lack of offense, and too often poor execution on defense, slowed the Stars down.
Nill brought him to be more of a physical presence. Lybushkin never really played much of a physical game; that was more Bichsel and Colin Blackwell.
3) Thomas Harley Overpaid
Nobody is saying that Thomas Harley is a bad defenseman. But paying just under $85 million over eight years has hurt the Stars’ ability to build a contender. Look at the Montreal Canadiens: a club that’s built a Stanley Cup threat without any salary cap woes.
Harley is still important to the team. His offense on the blue line and quarterbacking the power play make you want a player like Harley on your team. We also like seeing Harley show toughness by sticking up for his team and a willingness to fight.
4) Tyler Myers
Understandably looking to get bigger, Nill took a chance on 6’8″ Tyler Myers this spring. It hasn’t worked out for the 36-year-old defenseman.
Not only have the Stars suffered more in the neutral zone and on the score sheet, but Lian Bichsel’s natural development in the NHL has also been hindered.

5) Nill’s Far From All Bad
We don’t want to look only at the negatives here. Nill is one of the best general managers in the game for a reason. Nill has done far more to make the Stars improve than he has stumbled. We’ll be looking at just one example that transpired just this past week.
After parting ways with Remi Pourier (was put on waivers by Dallas, and is now with the New Jersey Devils organization), Nill followed the gloomy news with something to make Stars fans happy.
Casey DeSmith signed a two-year extension to keep arguably the NHL’s best goalie duo intact. Inking the deal on Wednesday, September 30th, to make sure the position stays solid for the next two years.
Discover more from Dallas Sports Nation
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Categorized:Stars
